Updated · BlushCue Editorial Team

How to choose a jewellery brand

Compare jewellery brands side by side on starting price and currency, metals, lab grown stones, product range, returns, warranty and who you are buying from, then narrow the field with rankings and reviews.

Start with the starting price, and read the currency

Price sorts a shortlist fastest, but read the currency before you compare anything. Ernest Jones sits in a different bracket altogether, since its range is fine jewellery, engagement rings, wedding bands and lab grown diamonds rather than low cost pieces.

Those figures sit in different currencies, so a fair comparison needs everything on the same scale. Remember too that an entry price tells you only about the cheapest item in a range, so look at what sits above it before you set a budget.

Read the metal before the stone

The metal shapes durability, care and price more than most shoppers expect, so compare the lists directly. Beaverbrooks covers the widest spread with gold, white gold and rose gold. Ernest Jones works in gold, white gold and rose gold, Capri Watch in gold, white gold and rose gold, BodyJewelry.com in gold and silver, and Sigma Imports Holdings in plated. If you want a solid metal rather than a plated one, a brand built around plating will not serve you.

Stones come next. Ernest Jones and Beaverbrooks both offer lab grown diamonds, while BodyJewelry.com and Capri Watch do not. If lab grown stones matter to you, those two names drop out before you ever compare prices, which saves you weighing figures that were never going to fit the brief.

Match the range to the occasion

Range breadth tells you how much of your needs one brand can cover. Beaverbrooks spans fine jewellery, fashion jewellery and engagement rings, and Ernest Jones covers fine jewellery, fashion jewellery and engagement rings, so both are plausible for a single shop for an engagement ring, a wedding band and a gift. Sigma Imports Holdings works in fashion jewellery and personalised, BodyJewelry.com in fashion jewellery, and Capri Watch in fashion, dress and dive, which are narrower briefs.

If you are buying a watch rather than a gem, movement narrows the field quickly. Beaverbrooks lists quartz, automatic and mechanical, while Capri Watch lists quartz. Check the Capri Watch review if a quartz only line tells you what you need to know about where that budget goes.

Read the returns window and the warranty together

Returns are the easiest numbers to compare, and the spread is wide. Beaverbrooks allows 30 days, Sigma Imports Holdings allows 30 days, and BodyJewelry.com allows 14 days. Across our listings data the return windows run up to 365 days, so a brand with a long window is doing real work for you if you are choosing between similar pieces.

Warranty and aftercare narrow the field just as much. Beaverbrooks carries a warranty of 1 year and includes resizing at no extra charge. Ask every brand on your shortlist the same pair of questions: how long the warranty runs, and what happens to the fit if the size is wrong. The answers separate retailers that support the piece afterwards from those that simply sell it.

Check who you are really buying from

Behind every shop name sits a registered company, and it is worth knowing which one you are dealing with. Beaverbrooks trades as Beaverbrooks the Jewellers Ltd, BodyJewelry.com as AGB Body Jewelry Inc., and Capri Watch as Asperula Stellina di Silvio Staiano SNC. Head offices sit in the United Kingdom, US and IT, which tells you which rules and delivery arrangements you are dealing with.

Where a brand ships tells you how useful it is for your address. Beaverbrooks serves GB and IE, Capri Watch serves IT and JP, and Sigma Imports Holdings reaches US, CA and GB. Support matters as much as reach: Beaverbrooks and BodyJewelry.com both offer email, chat and phone, while Sigma Imports Holdings offers email, phone and help centre, so live chat is one of the points to weigh.

Shortlist, then read the reviews

Longevity is a rough reliability signal, and the dates here are easy to check. Beaverbrooks was founded in 1919, Ernest Jones in 1949, and Capri Watch in 1964. A long trading history does not settle quality, but it tells you whether a brand is likely to be there when a warranty claim comes up.

Once your shortlist is down to two or three names, use the rankings and the individual write-ups. The jewellery brands ranking puts all of them in one place, and the Beaverbrooks review, Ernest Jones review, BodyJewelry.com review and Sigma Imports Holdings review fill in the detail that entry prices and metal lists leave out. Compare returns, warranty and support there, then choose on the brand that answers your specific question best.

See the full ranking: Top jewellery brands compared →

Sources