BodyJewelry.comNo. 5 of 249 in jewellery brands
9.4Best for: Budget piercing and fashion jewellery buyers in the US.
- Price from
- $2.95
- Lab-grown diamonds
- No
- Return window
- 14 days
- Legal entity
- AGB Body Jewelry Inc.
Alternatives to BodyJewelry.com
- Goettgen9.0
Our verdict
BodyJewelry.com suits shoppers buying piercing and fashion jewellery on a tight budget, with prices starting at $2.95 and a 14 day return window. Its entry price places it at 2 in the ranking, though a US base and a short returns window make it a weaker fit for buyers further afield.
Fits you if
- US shoppers after gold or silver piercing pieces at entry prices of $2.95.
- Buyers who want a focused range and nothing wider, since the catalogue is listed as fashion jewellery.
- Anyone who prefers to reach a person, with chat and phone among email, chat and phone.
Look elsewhere if
- Ernest Jones, for engagement rings, wedding bands and lab grown diamonds, all listed in fine jewellery, fashion jewellery and engagement rings.
- Beaverbrooks, for shoppers who want fine jewellery and personalised pieces in one catalogue, per fine jewellery, fashion jewellery and engagement rings.
- ArtGalleryZen, for personalised jewellery, listed in fashion jewellery and personalised.
Key facts
- Price from
- $2.95
- Lab-grown diamonds
- No
- Products
- Fashion jewellery
- Metals
- Gold, Silver
- Availability
- United States
- Return window
- 14 days
- Legal entity
- AGB Body Jewelry Inc.
- Headquarters
- United States
- Support channels
- Email, Chat, Phone, Help centre
- Official website
- Visit BodyJewelry.com
Facts checked 30 September 2026, 6 sources
Countries from the brand (Source, checked 30 September 2026)
Pros and cons
Pros
- Entry prices start at $2.95, ranking at 2 out of the 51 brands compared.
- Both gold and silver are available, so a shopper can stay in silver or move to gold within the same catalogue.
- Support runs on email, chat and phone, including chat and phone alongside email and a help centre.
- The range is deliberately narrow, listed as fashion jewellery, against fine jewellery, fashion jewellery and engagement rings at Beaverbrooks.
Cons
- Returns run 14 days, which places the brand at 45 out of the 55 brands compared on that measure.
- Lab grown is listed as no, so buyers after lab grown diamonds have to look to Ernest Jones or Beaverbrooks, both carrying lab grown diamonds in fine jewellery, fashion jewellery and engagement rings.
- A single product type, fashion jewellery, leaves engagement rings, wedding bands and fine jewellery outside the range.
What it does well
Returns are the clearest part of the offer: the stated window is 14 days, and the brand sets out its return and exchange terms directly. That window is short for a category where a piece has to sit well in place, so it suits buyers who know their size and style before ordering. The range is equally clear about its limits, with lab grown listed as no, which keeps the focus on conventional fashion pieces rather than lab made stones.
Who runs it
BodyJewelry.com is run by AGB Body Jewelry Inc., the legal entity given as AGB Body Jewelry Inc., and the business is based in the US per US. Support is the wider part of the setup: the listed channels are email, chat and phone, so questions can go through the help centre, by email, by chat or by phone. For a specialist retailer that is a generous spread of contact options, and it lets sizing and material questions be asked before an order is placed.
Questions
What does BodyJewelry.com cost?
Prices start at $2.95 for the cheapest listed earrings, and the range is fashion jewellery throughout. That entry point places the brand at 2 out of the 51 brands compared, so BodyJewelry.com sits among the cheapest starting prices in the set rather than in the middle of it.
How long are returns allowed for?
Returns run 14 days under the stated return and exchange terms, with exchanges handled as part of the same policy. That is a tight window for a category where a piercing has to sit correctly, and it ranks the brand at 45 out of the 55 brands compared, low down for such a measure.
Does BodyJewelry.com sell lab grown stones?
Lab grown is listed as no, and the range is limited to fashion jewellery. Anyone choosing between a piercing specialist and a general jewellery retailer gets a broader choice from Ernest Jones or Beaverbrooks, since fine jewellery, fashion jewellery and engagement rings both include lab grown diamonds.
Which metals are available?
The stated metals are gold and silver, so the choice runs between silver and gold. Both appear within a catalogue that starts at $2.95, which makes it easy to hold one metal and move along the price range without changing material or retailer.
Where is the company based, and who runs it?
BodyJewelry.com is run by AGB Body Jewelry Inc., the legal entity given as AGB Body Jewelry Inc., and the business is based in the US per US. The US base matters for anyone ordering from outside the country, since delivery times and any import duty sit outside the item price.
How can I get help?
Support runs on email, chat and phone: the help centre, email, chat and phone. A shopper can check sizing, materials and return terms before buying and still reach a person afterwards, which suits anyone who prefers a conversation to a form.
How does the range compare with the other brands listed?
BodyJewelry.com lists fashion jewellery, a single focused category. ArtGalleryZen is listed with fashion jewellery and personalised, and Beaverbrooks with fine jewellery, fashion jewellery and engagement rings, so buyers who want a mixed catalogue of fine, personalised and occasion jewellery have wider options elsewhere.
How does the brand score on this comparison?
The overall score is 9.4, split into a cost part of 10 and an offer part of 8.8. The cost part reflects the low entry price of $2.95, while the offer part sits lower, consistent with the 14 day return window and the absence of lab grown pieces.
Sources
- bodyjewelry.com checked 30 September 2026
Backs: Products
“Shop BodyJewelry.com - over 5,000 body piercing jewelry styles in titanium, surgical steel & 14K gold”
- bodyjewelry.com/about-us checked 30 September 2026
Backs: Metals
“Our selections include jewelry made from 316L Surgical Grade Stainless Steel, .925 Sterling Silver, Solid 14k Gold and Solid Titanium.”
- bodyjewelry.com/return-and-exchange checked 30 September 2026
Backs: Return window, Support channels
“you start the return within 14 days of the delivery date (based on the postmark)”
- bodyjewelry.com/search.php checked 30 September 2026
Backs: Price from
“Replacement Horseshoe Circular Barbell Bar | Luxe Modz ... Our Price: $2.95”
- bodyjewelry.com/shop-by-categories/nose-rings checked 30 September 2026
Backs: Lab-grown diamonds
“Real Diamond Nose Ring”
- bodyjewelry.com/terms-and-conditions checked 30 September 2026
Backs: Headquarters, Legal entity
“AGB Body Jewelry Inc., located at 1755 Banks Road, Margate, FL 33063, United States”
Compiled from 6 source pages, checked 30 September 2026. We did not open an account.





























