Updated 17 November 2026 · BlushCue Editorial Team

Top beauty boxes and advent calendars compared

14 brands, ranked on the terms we checked.

Offers you can use come first, then value, then score, so a lower score can lead.

What matters most

BrandScoreFree deliveryFree delivery threshold Read moreSupport channelsReturn windowFree samples
  • 1

    IPSY

    Top pick

    Best for: A monthly beauty box for shoppers who would rather be surprised than shop.

    9.2
    $10
    Chat, Help centre, Community
    Not listed
    Not listed
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Support channels
    Chat, Help centre, Community
    Return window
    Not listed
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers who enjoy a monthly beauty box with samples and would rather leave the choice to someone else.
    • Repeat buyers, since the loyalty scheme rewards coming back for full sizes of what the box introduced.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Shoppers who want to browse once rather than take a monthly box: Ulta Beauty covers the same set, skincare, makeup and haircare.
    • Shoppers who want the same skincare, makeup and haircare spread from a general retailer instead of a membership box.
    Free delivery threshold
    $10
    Markets
    United States, Canada, Mexico
    Legal entity
    Personalized Beauty Discovery, Inc.
    Headquarters
    United States
    Read review
  • 2

    Ulta Beauty

    Top pick

    Best for: US shoppers buying across several beauty categories in one place, with a loyalty scheme and a 30-day return window.

    9.5
    Not listed
    Phone, Chat, Email +1
    30 days
    Not listed
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Return window
    30 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers in the US who want skincare, makeup, haircare, fragrance and beauty boxes in a single order.
    • Regular buyers who value a loyalty programme next to their beauty spending.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Notino.cz, if a 90-day return window matters more than a broad skincare, makeup and haircare range.
    • DocMorris, if a tighter store range covering skincare, makeup and haircare suits a more focused shop.
    Support channels
    Phone, Chat, Email, and 1 more
    Markets
    United States
    Legal entity
    Ulta Beauty, Inc.
    Headquarters
    United States
    Founded
    1990
    Read review
  • 3

    SkinStore

    Top pick

    Best for: A single store for skincare, makeup and haircare in US and CA, with a returns window of 60 days.

    9.0
    $50
    Help centre
    60 days
    Yes
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Support channels
    Help centre
    Return window
    60 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers in US and CA building a full routine across skincare, makeup and haircare.
    • People who like to try before they commit, since free samples and a returns window of 60 days both apply.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Notino, if grooming matters to you, since its store categories include grooming in skincare, makeup and haircare while skincare, makeup and haircare stops short of it.
    • Ulta Beauty, if you want a broader mixed basket, because skincare, makeup and haircare adds grooming and jewellery to the same skincare, makeup and fragrance range.
    Free delivery threshold
    $50
    Free samples
    Yes
    Markets
    United States, Canada
    Legal entity
    The Hut.com Ltd t/a Dermstore.com
    Headquarters
    United States
    Founded
    1999
    • Cost8.8
    • Offer9.0
    • Trust9.4
    Read review
  • 4

    LOOKFANTASTIC

    Top pick

    Best for: A single basket for beauty, hair and fragrance, with a 30 days return window.

    8.9
    £25
    Help centre
    30 days
    Not listed
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Support channels
    Help centre
    Return window
    30 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers buying across several categories at once, since skincare, makeup and haircare sit side by side in one order.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Not for jewellery buyers: Glambou lists jewellery and nothing else.
    • Not for shoppers who want a shorter beauty edit: DocMorris stops at skincare, makeup and haircare.
    Free delivery threshold
    £25
    Brands stocked
    from 660
    Markets
    United Kingdom, Andorra, Bosnia and Herzegovina, and 85 more
    Legal entity
    The Hut.com Ltd
    Headquarters
    United Kingdom
    Read review
  • 5

    GLOSSYBOX

    Top pick

    Best for: A monthly beauty box at a low entry price, with a straightforward returns window.

    8.8
    £35
    Email, Help centre
    14 days
    No
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Support channels
    Email, Help centre
    Return window
    14 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers in the markets served, who can order without worrying about international delivery
    • Anyone starting with a small beauty spend and moving to a regular box

    Look elsewhere if

    • Shoppers after a wide catalogue, since store categories cover beauty boxes only
    • Anyone relying on trial samples, as free samples are not offered
    Free delivery threshold
    £35
    Free samples
    No
    Markets
    United Kingdom, Guernsey, Jersey
    Legal entity
    THG Beauty Limited
    Headquarters
    United Kingdom
    Read review
  • 6

    Beauty Pie

    Top pick

    Best for: Fragrance and colour shoppers in GB and US who want a loyalty scheme and a returns window of 14 to 30 days.

    8.7
    Not listed
    Help centre, Email
    14 to 30 days
    Not listed
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Support channels
    Help centre, Email
    Return window
    14 to 30 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Anyone who values a returns window of 14 to 30 days when experimenting with colour.
    • Beauty box buyers, since beauty boxes sit inside skincare, makeup and haircare alongside skin, makeup, haircare and fragrance.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Grooming and jewellery shoppers, who will find both in Notino.cz and Ulta Beauty rather than in skincare, makeup and haircare.
    • Shoppers who want one shelf list for everything, since skincare, makeup and haircare and skincare, makeup and haircare both add grooming to the categories Beauty Pie carries.
    Markets
    United Kingdom, United States
    Legal entity
    Beauty Pie Limited
    Headquarters
    United Kingdom
    Founded
    2015
    Read review
  • 7

    Notino.hr

    Top pick

    Best for: A wide catalogue, a long return window and a loyalty programme from a single storefront.

    8.7
    €70
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    90 days
    No
    Loyalty scheme
    Yes
    Support channels
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    Return window
    90 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers who want a long returns window before committing to a new skincare or hair routine.
    • Buyers assembling a mixed basket, since store categories run skincare, makeup and haircare.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Not for Ulta Beauty loyalists who count on free samples: its free samples answer is a yes, Notino.hr's is no.
    • Not for Notino shoppers on the Portuguese site who plan around free samples, since free samples are a yes there.
    Free delivery threshold
    €70
    Free samples
    No
    Brands stocked
    1,150 to 1,800
    Markets
    Czechia, Slovakia, Poland, and 24 more
    Legal entity
    Notino s.r.o.
    Headquarters
    Czechia
    Founded
    2004
    • Cost8.2
    • Offer9.1
    • Trust9.0
    Read review
The price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read moreWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read moreCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more

About this ranking

Beauty boxes sit inside a bigger question: who sells them at a fair price, what they contain and how easily one can be sent back. This ranking of 18 beauty retailers covers shops that run boxes alongside skincare, makeup, haircare, fragrance and grooming, so a subscription shopper and a gift buyer can be compared on the same page. The main trade-off is breadth against flexibility: retailers with the largest catalogues and the most markets usually promise less time to change your mind, while those with generous return policies tend to sell a narrower range or serve fewer countries. Each entry below names the fit, then the trade-off.

How we picked

Every brand here is scored on published figures only, drawn from each retailer's own store, delivery, returns, help and about pages, plus the site-level data behind this category. Where entries look alike on paper, the tie breaks towards the longer return window, then the wider market list, then the larger catalogue. Category spread carries real weight in this group, because beauty boxes rarely travel alone, and a retailer boxing a single line is a different proposition from a generalist boxing several. Membership purchases and single orders are treated separately, since a subscriber cares about what arrives each month while a gift buyer cares about the total at checkout. Figures keep the source's qualifiers, including market limits, so a policy that applies in one country is never read as a worldwide rule.

How we rank

Picks by need

  • Best forUS shoppers buying across several beauty categories in one place, with a loyalty scheme and a 30-day return

    Ulta Beauty logoUlta Beauty

    Its skincare, makeup and haircare put beauty boxes next to skincare, makeup, haircare, fragrance and grooming, support is offered on phone, chat and email, and a loyalty scheme rewards return visits at a company trading since 1990.

  • Best forA single store for skincare, makeup and haircare in US and CA, with a returns window of 60 days

    SkinStore logoSkinStore

    It serves US and CA and free delivery starts at $50, so the box economics line up with Dermstore's. Where the two differ is only in what a shopper already holds, so the choice between them is an account question rather than a terms question.

What to look for

Price at entry
Compare what the first box costs against the spread across this category.
Return window
A long return window is the safety net that matters when shades or sizes land wrong. Return periods in this ranking run 0 to 90 days, and the gap between the shortest policy and the most generous is the largest single difference between otherwise similar entries.
Category spread
Boxes rarely stand alone, so check what sits beside them.
Help when a box goes wrong
Boxes arrive on a schedule, so support matters when one goes wrong.
Samples and extras
Small extras decide how generous a box feels. Samples come with orders from 93% of the entries and free samples from 70%, which is often the difference between a box that feels worth the money and one that feels thin.
Loyalty and repeat boxes
If boxes are a habit rather than a gift, check the rewards side.

Questions

Which shop has the longest return window?

The Notino storefronts sit at the top here, with 90 days in the Czech Republic, 90 days on the Portuguese site and 90 days for UK shoppers, against a category range of 0 to 90 days. Dermstore follows at 60 days, while the shortest policy in this ranking belongs to IPSY at 0 days, so members there should settle contents before a box is opened.

Which retailers offer free delivery?

Check the threshold before ordering, since a single box often sits below it.

What do boxes usually cost?

Most boxes here sit in a modest price band, and prices come in dollars, pounds and euros. A monthly box and a seasonal advent calendar are priced on different terms, so compare like with like and check whether delivery is included.

Which shop covers the most markets?

The Notino sites have the widest reach, with CZ, SK and PL on the Portuguese storefront and GB, CZ and SK for the UK site, against CZ for the Czech site and US for Ulta Beauty. SweetCare covers AT, BE and BG, while narrower entries such as L'Atelier du Sourcil at FR, AD and BE suit buyers who shop in one region.

Do any of these shops run a loyalty scheme?

Most do, and that shapes the value of a repeat box. Ulta Beauty, SweetCare, Dermstore, Perfumería Comas, IPSY and the Notino sites in the Czech Republic and the UK all run a loyalty scheme, while the Portuguese Notino site, L'Atelier du Sourcil and This is Beauty do not. Free samples also come with orders from several of those same shops, adding value to each delivery.

Which shops box the widest range of products?

Every entry in this ranking lists beauty boxes, but the breadth differs. The generalists, from Notino.cz and the Notino sites through Ulta Beauty, SweetCare, Perfumería Comas, Dermstore, IPSY and This is Beauty, list skincare, makeup, haircare, fragrance, grooming and beauty boxes, as skincare, makeup and haircare shows, while L'Atelier du Sourcil covers skincare, makeup and haircare with jewellery in place of fragrance and grooming.

Keep comparing