Updated · BlushCue Editorial Team

How to choose a skincare brand

Entry prices, product ranges, sun protection ceilings, returns windows, certifications and support are what separate skincare brands, so compare them one step at a time instead of on price alone.

Start with entry price and currency

Every figure below is an entry point rather than a typical basket, so check the currency and the product it belongs to before you compare anything. Cosmetics lists $4.

Currency and purchase route both change what the number means. Entry prices are listed in different currencies across this group, so compare figures inside the same currency and treat a cross-currency gap as a shipping question rather than a value question. The plan matters as well: an entry price is a single product purchase, while Every Man Jack also runs a subscription, so repeat orders follow that route instead of a fresh checkout.

Read the range before the price

Brands can share an entry price and still not be comparable, because the lowest figure buys different things. e.l.f. Cosmetics lists foundation, concealer, lipstick, mascara, eyeshadow and brows, so its entry price sits inside colour cosmetics. Innisfree lists cleansers, moisturisers, serums, sunscreen, retinoids, acne, anti-ageing, k-beauty and body-care, so its entry price sits inside a treatment range. Check product types against what you actually need before the price matters at all.

Category focus also shows how deep a range runs. Every Man Jack lists beard-care, mens-skincare and body-grooming, a narrow and clearly aimed shelf rather than a full facial range. Murad, meanwhile, is built on a peta certification and cruelty free status rather than a shelf you can read at a glance. The Innisfree review and the e.l.f. Cosmetics review show how each range is built out in practice.

Set sun protection and skin type first

Sun protection is the easiest ceiling to compare because brands state a maximum factor. The highest factor listed for Innisfree is 50, e.l.f. Cosmetics reaches 50 and Every Man Jack lists 30. Where that ceiling sits tells you how much of a range is daily-protection product rather than treatment product.

Skin-type coverage widens or narrows the same picture. Innisfree lists dry, oily, combination, sensitive, acne-prone and mature. Every Man Jack narrows its claim to sensitive. If your skin is oily or acne-prone, the wider list is the sensible starting point, and the Every Man Jack review sets out how its sensitive-skin positioning is framed.

Returns windows and how long you have to decide

A returns window is a practical limit on how long you can test a product before deciding. e.l.f. Cosmetics sets its window at 14 to 30 days, and Every Man Jack gives 30 days. A wider window means more testing time, while a narrower one pushes you towards smaller opening orders.

Returns are also where the legal entity matters, because the party named in the terms is the one you claim against. Read the returns wording next to the support channels below instead of treating the window as a promise on its own.

Certifications, vegan claims and free-from lists

Certification lists are quick to check and quick to misread. e.l.f. Cosmetics holds leaping-bunny and peta, Every Man Jack holds b-corp, and Murad holds peta. e.l.f. Cosmetics, Every Man Jack and Murad are each cruelty free, and e.l.f. Cosmetics is vegan as well.

Free-from lists overlap rather than separate. e.l.f. Cosmetics and Every Man Jack both leave out parabens and sulfates. A shared free-from list is not a formula comparison, so treat it as a filter that narrows the field rather than a verdict on which brand performs better.

Who is behind the brand and where it ships

The legal entity tells you who you are dealing with. Innisfree sells as Innisfree Co., Ltd., e.l.f. Cosmetics as e.l.f. Cosmetics, Inc., Every Man Jack as Presidio Brands, Inc. And Murad as Murad LLC. How long a brand has traded adds context: Murad was founded in 1989, Innisfree in 2000 and Every Man Jack in 2006.

Where each brand ships narrows what you can order at all. e.l.f. Cosmetics lists US, CA, IN, PL and ES. Every Man Jack lists US and CA. Murad lists US, CA, GB, MY, AU and DE. Innisfree is headquartered in South Korea. If you sit outside those markets, price and returns are the wrong place to begin.

Support channels and where to read the detail

Support channels tell you how quickly you can get an answer when a product does not suit. Innisfree offers email, chat, phone and a help centre. e.l.f. Cosmetics offers email, phone, a help centre and a community. Every Man Jack offers email, chat and a help centre. Broader coverage, including a phone line, usually means a faster route for a return or an ingredient query.

Use the rankings and the individual reviews together. The skincare brand rankings put the field in order, and the Murad review gives the detail behind an individual entry. Work through the steps in order: product range and sun protection first, then entry price, returns windows, certifications and support.

See the full ranking: Top skincare brands compared →

Sources