Start by working out what you are buying
The first question is not price, it is kind. e.l.f. Cosmetics builds its own colour cosmetics, working across foundation, concealer and lipstick. Innisfree builds skincare, across cleansers, moisturisers and serums. Notino is a retailer that lists 1,800 brands under skincare, makeup and haircare. A shade or price comparison across those three is only fair once you know which side of the counter you are on, because a maker sets its own range while a shop simply passes it through.
The maker behind each name is also worth pinning down early. e.l.f. Cosmetics trades as e.l.f. Cosmetics, Inc. Out of US. Innisfree trades as Innisfree Co., Ltd. In KR, founded in 2000. Notino trades as Notino Italia s.r.l. Out of CZ, founded in 2004. The makeup brand rankings are a sensible place to widen the field before you commit.
Entry price, and how to read it honestly
An entry price shows the least you can spend to try a brand, not what a finished look costs. e.l.f. Those figures sit in different currencies, so ranking them as printed is meaningless; convert before you compare, and treat the retailer’s entry figure as a bottle, not a look.
A unit measure tightens the comparison. Notino lists a price of 11.38 euros for a designer fragrance, which lets you weigh a full bottle against a 11 euros entry item and see which side of the shop your budget is really going on.
Shade range is the number that ends most searches
Shade count decides whether a foundation is worth testing at all, and it is where these options look least alike. The e.l.f. Cosmetics satin foundation offers 36 shades, wide enough to cover most undertones in its range. Across the listings we hold the spread is 0 to 67 shades, which is the useful benchmark when a brand makes a broad claim.
notino’s own foundation shade count is 0 shades, so shade matching is not work the retailer does for you read the shade list on the brand page before you buy. Innisfree sits outside this part of the comparison altogether, because it does not sell foundation. If matching your skin tone is the hard part of your order, that alone rules brands in and out.
Check what the range actually covers
Category fit decides how much of a basket a brand can absorb. e.l.f. Cosmetics is organised around colour, covering foundation, concealer and lipstick without straying far from it. Innisfree is a care brand, sitting across cleansers, moisturisers and serums and organised for dry, oily and combination. Notino spans the widest ground, from skincare and makeup through haircare, fragrance, grooming and beauty boxes, with fragrance running parfum, edp and edt plus samples and home fragrance.
Read this as a shopping list match. A basket of base, liner and brow points at e.l.f. Cosmetics. A basket built around a daily routine with a scent at the end points at notino, where a single order can cover more ground than a pair of maker websites. The notino review is where the retailer’s range is set out in more detail.
The numbers that do not separate them, and should be retired
Sun protection is a tie and should not decide anything. Innisfree, e.l.f. Cosmetics and notino all top out at 50, 50 and 50 respectively. Skin type coverage is close to a tie too: Innisfree and notino publish the same list, dry, oily and combination, while e.l.f. Cosmetics organises its range by product type rather than by skin. Put your effort into shade range, unit price and returns instead.
Ingredient standards, and the open questions
In colour cosmetics the standards questions are narrow: cruelty free, vegan, and what has been left out. e.l.f. Cosmetics answers each of them. It is cruelty free, it is vegan, it holds leaping bunny and peta certification, and its formulas are made without parabens and sulfates.
Innisfree is a maker of care products rather than colour, and the information we hold for it does not include a cruelty free or vegan line. Treat that as an open question rather than a verdict, and weigh it alongside the review pages for e.l.f. Cosmetics and Innisfree, where formulation detail sits next to price.
Returns, delivery and where you can actually buy
This is the section that moves the arithmetic most. e.l.f. Cosmetics ships to US, CA and allows returns within 14 to 30 days. Notino reaches CZ, SK and PL, accepts returns within 90 days and waives delivery above 45 euros. That threshold is the figure to plan around, because an order beneath it costs more per bottle than the entry price suggests.
Perks differ as well. Notino runs no loyalty programme, so nothing compounds across orders, though free samples soften a first buy. Support is close but not identical: email, phone and help centre at the retailer against email, phone and help centre at e.l.f. Cosmetics and email, chat and phone at Innisfree. A long returns window is only useful if there is a channel you can actually reach to start one.
A simple order of operations
Decide first whether you want a maker or a shop, because that trims the shortlist. If you want your own colour cosmetics, compare e.l.f. Cosmetics on shade count, certification and entry price, and read the MAC Cosmetics and Clinique pages for a wider comparison on range and returns.
If you want a single basket to cover the whole order, compare retailers on delivery thresholds, returns windows and breadth of stock rather than on any single product price. The Ulta Beauty and YesStyle pages give you further reference points there.