Updated · BlushCue Editorial Team

How to choose haircare brands

Entry price, hair types covered, ingredient lists, returns and the company behind the label are the checks that separate haircare brands, and this guide works through each one with the numbers attached.

Entry price tells you the shelf, not the cost of a routine

Both figures are entry points for a single purchase, not the price of a full routine, because a shampoo, a conditioner and a treatment will not cost what one bottle costs.

Every Man Jack also offers a subscription, so anyone buying the same product repeatedly has two prices to weigh: the one-off shelf price and the subscription rate. Jessicurl and Redken are listed by product line rather than as subscriptions, so the single purchase price is the only figure to compare there.

Notino.cz sits differently from the specialist hair labels. It is a retailer that also sells shampoos, so its hair prices sit inside the same overall span and should be compared against the specialist brands only once you have checked delivery terms.

Match the range to the hair you actually have

Hair type coverage is the fastest way to cut a shortlist. Redken lists its products for curly and colour treated hair and sells across shampoo, conditioner and treatments, so its range is broad in category but stated for a narrower set of hair types than Jessicurl.

Jessicurl lists straight, wavy and curly, which is the broadest hair type coverage of the brands here, and its product types span shampoo, conditioner and treatments. If your hair sits at the edge of that list, Jessicurl is the brand whose range does the least narrowing.

Notino.cz shampoo listings cover wavy, curly and fine. Every Man Jack is the outlier here: its product types are beard care, mens skincare and body grooming, so its hair offering sits next to grooming rather than alongside a full shampoo and conditioning line, and its listed skin types include sensitive with sun protection up to 30.

Look at the company behind the label

The legal entity tells you who stands behind a product when something goes wrong. Redken sells under L’Oreal (UK) Limited, Every Man Jack under Presidio Brands, Inc., Jessicurl, LLC and Notino.cz under Notino, s.r.o. A parent company and an independent business are not better or worse, but they answer different questions about accountability and continuity.

Age gives a rough sense of how established a brand is: Redken has been trading since 1960, Jessicurl since 2002, Notino.cz since 2004 and Every Man Jack since 2006. Every Man Jack also holds b corp certification, which is a third-party check on its practices rather than a product claim.

On animal testing, both Every Man Jack and Jessicurl are cruelty free.

Ingredient lists separate lookalike shelves

Two shelves can look alike and still exclude different things, so the free-from list does the sorting. Every Man Jack excludes parabens and sulfates, Jessicurl excludes fragrance, parabens and sulfates. Jessicurl’s list is the longer of the two and includes fragrance, silicones and alcohol alongside parabens and sulfates.

Read those lists against the hair types you settled on in the previous step. A brand that covers more hair types and excludes more ingredients is making a broader claim, and the review pages are where you can see how that claim is received.

Returns and delivery decide the real cost of a bad choice

Jessicurl allows 60 days for returns, compared with 30 days at Every Man Jack. On a small basket of products that is the difference between a formula you can send back with time to spare and one you cannot.

Where a brand ships narrows the same question. Every Man Jack ships to the United States and Canada, Jessicurl to US, and Notino.cz to CZ, so its shoppers face a single market and the rest of its offer depends on what a domestic order delivers.

Notino.cz also lists fragrance concentrations across parfum, extrait and edp and a foundation shade count of 0 shades, so it earns its place in fragrance and makeup comparisons rather than in a haircare shortlist.

Support channels show how fast a problem gets fixed

Redken offers email, chat and phone, the widest mix listed here, which suits anyone who wants phone or chat as well as written answers. Jessicurl offers email, phone and help centre and Every Man Jack offers email, chat and help centre, both of which lean on self-service help centres.

Where support is thinner, the returns window matters more, because the brand is the only route to a resolution. Pair that with the review pages: read the Redken notes against the support channels above, then do the same for Every Man Jack, Jessicurl and Notino.cz before you commit to a basket.

Close the shortlist against the rankings

Run your candidates back through the haircare brands ranking with the checks above in hand: entry price against the overall span, hair type coverage against your own hair, exclusions against your sensitivities, and the returns window against the support channels on offer.

Where a brand scores well on one line and badly on another, that is the trade-off to decide rather than a defect to fix. Every Man Jack is a case in point: a lower entry price and a wider delivery footprint sit beside a range built around grooming rather than a full hair routine, so it suits some shoppers and rules itself out for others.

See the full ranking: Top haircare brands compared →

Sources