Start with breadth, because it decides what you can buy at all
The first thing to check is how many brands a retailer carries and which market you are shopping in. Notino.cz lists 1,150 brands and serves CZ, while notino lists 1,800 brands across CZ, SK and PL. A wider catalogue matters most when you are chasing a specific niche fragrance, since a small store simply may not carry it.
Breadth only helps if it reaches the aisle you need. Notino.cz sells skincare, makeup and haircare, and notino covers skincare, makeup and haircare. If you are still narrowing the field, the beauty retailer rankings put the shortlist side by side before you start reading individual profiles.
Read the price per millilitre, not the headline price
A low starting price tells you little, because a cheap tester size is not what most people repurchase. The comparison that holds up is the price per millilitre, which lets you weigh a large flacon against a small one. Notino works out at 11.38 euros against CZK 78.50 at Notino.cz, and the full bottle details sit in the notino review and the Notino.cz review.
Convert before you compare, and keep the per millilitre figure alongside the basket total so a low entry price does not hide an expensive refill.
Check that the range matches your skin, hair and sun protection
Depth only matters if it covers the products you intend to buy. Notino.cz filters for dry, oily and sensitive and notino for dry, oily and combination, so sensitive, acne-prone and mature skin are all addressable, and both cap sun protection at 50. Hair is better covered at Notino.cz, which lists wavy, curly and fine including wavy, curly and colour-treated hair.
Makeup is where the coverage divides most clearly. Notino.cz lists 0 foundation shades and notino lists 0 shades, so if you need a specific base match, read the Ulta Beauty review instead. Ulta Beauty is also cruelty free, which Notino.cz and notino do not state. On fragrance, the two Notino sites go deeper: Notino.cz offers parfum, extrait and edp including extrait, while notino and Ulta Beauty list parfum, edp and edt.
Work out when free delivery kicks in
Delivery thresholds quietly change the total more than most shoppers expect. Splitting an order to slip under a threshold usually backfires on postage, so compare against the whole basket.
Two things also change what you pay at checkout. Notino.cz has a loyalty scheme, which notino does not. Notino.cz offers samples, and notino also offers samples along with free samples, so fragrance testers and gifts are easier to find on the Notino sites than elsewhere in the shortlist.
Returns and support decide how risky a first order feels
Returns are where the shortlist spreads out most. The span across the retailers covered runs up to 90 days, and Notino.cz and notino both give 90 days. A long window matters most for fragrance and colour cosmetics, where buying blind is the normal case, and it matters least for a skincare repeat order you already know.
If a return goes wrong, support channels decide how fast it resolves. Notino.cz offers phone, email and help centre and notino offers email, phone and help centre, so a question can be raised by phone or email at either. Wider comparisons sit in the DocMorris review, the Glambou review and the MoreThisWay review.