In short
A pre-owned seller stating that every watch it sells has been checked to confirm it is genuine.
Authenticity check means a pre-owned seller states that every watch it sells has been checked to confirm it is genuine, which is the main risk when buying second hand. ashford, Bob’s Watches and Goldsmiths all say yes, so they carry that promise in this group. Bulova and motorola say no, so no such check is promised. Ask who carried out the check and whether it comes with a guarantee, because the word on its own can cover very little.