Updated 17 October 2026 · BlushCue Editorial Team

Mented Cosmetics vs Natasha Denona Makeup

Mented Cosmetics logo

Mented Cosmetics

No. 2 of 126 in makeup brands9.0

Best for: A cruelty free, vegan all-in-one range for sensitive and oily skin, starting at $8.

Natasha Denona Makeup logo

Natasha Denona Makeup

No. 5 of 126 in makeup brands8.6

Best for: Shoppers who want a deep foundation shade match in a cruelty free range.

See the category

Key differences

  • Mented Cosmetics scores higher overall: 9.0 against 8.6.
  • Mented Cosmetics has a lower entry price ($8 against $24).
  • Natasha Denona Makeup is available in 29 more countries.
  • Among products, only Mented Cosmetics offers Mascara, Brows and Lashes.

Side by side

Mented Cosmetics vs Natasha Denona Makeup
Mented Cosmetics logoMented CosmeticsNatasha Denona Makeup logoNatasha Denona Makeup
Cost and Offer
Price from$8Lowerin the lowest quarter of 45 brands$24above the median of 45 brands
Foundation shades16 shadesabove the median of 70 brands52 shadesHigherin the highest quarter of 70 brands
Cruelty-freeYesYes
Vegan rangeYesNo
Other facts
ProductsFoundation, Concealer, Lipstick, Mascara, Eyeshadow, Brows
+ 2 moreLashes, Nails
Foundation, Concealer, Lipstick, Eyeshadow
MarketsUnited States, Canada, United KingdomUnited States, Mexico, Canada, Belize, Costa Rica, El Salvador
+ 27 moreGuatemala, Honduras, Nicaragua, Panama, Antigua and Barbuda, Bahamas, Cuba, Dominica, Dominican Republic, Grenada, Haiti, Jamaica, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Trinidad and Tobago, Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Guyana, Paraguay, Peru, Suriname, Uruguay, Venezuela
Return window30 days30 days
Company
Legal entityNot listedNatasha Denona Makeup LLC
HeadquartersUnited StatesNot listed
Founded2017Not listed
Support channelsEmail, Help centreEmail, Help centre

Our verdict on each

Mented Cosmetics

Mented Cosmetics is a cruelty free, vegan US brand that suits shoppers with sensitive or oily skin who want face, lip, eye, lash and nail products under one roof. Entry prices of $8 and 30 days returns keep it a value pick, with an overall score of 9.

Read the full Mented Cosmetics review

Natasha Denona Makeup

Natasha Denona Makeup suits shoppers who want depth in shades and a cruelty free range rather than a wide category list. Its Hy Glam foundation alone carries 52 shades, and the range starts at $24, which is where the money question comes in.

Read the full Natasha Denona Makeup review

If neither fits

Pros and cons

Mented Cosmetics

Pros

  • A range of 16 foundation shades gives room to match tone without a sprawling catalogue.
  • It is cruelty free and vegan, and the formulas are free from parabens.
  • Returns run 30 days, long enough to wear a shade for a full day before deciding.

Cons

  • Support runs on email and help centre only, with no live chat or phone line listed.
  • Sun protection is thin on the ground, with SPF topping out at 0.
  • Skin type coverage is limited to sensitive and oily, so dry or mature skin has less to go on.

Natasha Denona Makeup

Pros

  • The brand is cruelty free across the range, so a wide shade choice comes without that compromise.
  • Shade depth is the headline number: 52 shades in the Hy Glam foundation.
  • Returns run 30 days, enough to wear a foundation through a full day before deciding.

Cons

  • The range is not vegan, which rules out a vegan-only shopper.
  • Support runs on email and help centre only, with no phone line or live chat listed.
  • The range covers foundation, concealer and lipstick, thinner than foundation, concealer and lipstick and foundation, concealer and eyeshadow.

Who each suits

Mented Cosmetics

Who it suits

  • Shoppers with sensitive or oily skin who want a cruelty free, vegan range to build one basket around.
  • Value buyers checking foundation shade depth and entry price in the same pass, since 16 shades start at $8.
  • Anyone who prefers self-serve help, with questions answered by email or through the help centre.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Shoppers who want lashes and nails in the same basket, since innisfree’s listed range is foundation, concealer and eyeshadow.
  • Shoppers whose routine stops at face, lips and eyes, as e.l.f. Cosmetics lists foundation, concealer and lipstick.

Natasha Denona Makeup

Who it suits

  • Shoppers who need a deep shade match and will pay $24 and upward for a cruelty free range.
  • Eyeshadow shoppers, since eyeshadow sits in foundation, concealer and lipstick next to foundation, concealer and lipstick.

Who should look elsewhere

  • Shoppers who want a single brand for lashes, brows and nails, because foundation, concealer and lipstick covers a much longer category list than foundation, concealer and lipstick.
  • Vegan-only shoppers, since the range is not vegan.

Questions about each

Mented Cosmetics

What does Mented Cosmetics cost?

Colour cosmetics prices start at $8. That entry point keeps Mented Cosmetics within reach for shoppers who want several products in one basket, and the range spans foundation, concealer, lips, eyes, lashes and nails rather than resting on one hero product.

How many foundation shades are offered?

Mented Cosmetics lists 16 foundation shades, which puts it near the middle of the brands tracked on shade depth rather than at either extreme. Shade details are published as a comparison guide, so tone can be matched before ordering.

Natasha Denona Makeup

What does Natasha Denona Makeup cost at entry?

Prices start at $24, set by the lowest priced item in the range rather than by a foundation price. That entry point ranks 63 of 74 brands on the price-from table, placing Natasha Denona Makeup in the dearer part of the group. Shoppers on a tight budget find a cheaper starting point with one of the alternatives listed.

How many foundation shades are available?

The Hy Glam foundation carries 52 shades, the widest part of the offer. On shade count the brand sits at 3 of 76 in the ranking, so the depth is a real strength rather than a marketing line. A shopper with an unusual undertone has a better chance of a close match here than with a short shade list.

Sources

Mented Cosmetics

  • mentedcosmetics.com: 10 facts, checked 30 September 2026

Natasha Denona Makeup

  • natashadenona.com: 9 facts, checked 30 September 2026