Updated 30 September 2026 · BlushCue Editorial Team
e.l.f. Cosmetics vs Olay

e.l.f. Cosmetics
9.7Best for: For cheap, cruelty free makeup with a wide foundation shade range.
Olay
9.5Best for: A single brand for a full face and body routine at an entry level price.
Key differences
- e.l.f. Cosmetics scores higher overall: 9.7 against 9.5.
- e.l.f. Cosmetics has a lower entry price ($4 against $6.99).
- Among support channels, only e.l.f. Cosmetics offers Community.
- Among support channels, only Olay offers Chat.
- e.l.f. Cosmetics is available in 4 more countries.
Side by side
e.l.f. Cosmetics | Olay | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost and Offer | ||
| Price from | $4Lower | $6.99 |
| Cruelty-free | Yes | Yes |
| Vegan range | Yes | Not listed |
| Highest SPF | 50 | 40 |
| Certifications | Leaping bunny, Peta | Not listed |
| Other facts | ||
| Products | Foundation, Concealer, Lipstick, Mascara, Eyeshadow, Brows | Cleansers, Moisturisers, Serums, Sunscreen, Retinoids, Anti ageing+ 2 moreAcne, Body care |
| Skin types | Not listed | Dry, Oily, Combination, Sensitive, Acne prone |
| Free from | Parabens, Sulfates | Not listed |
| Markets | United States, Canada, India, Poland, Spain | United States |
| Return window | 14 to 30 days | 30 days |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | e.l.f. Cosmetics, Inc. | The Procter & Gamble Company |
| Headquarters | United States | United States |
| Support channels | Email, Phone, Help centre, Community | Email, Chat, Phone, Help centre |
Our verdict on each
e.l.f. Cosmetics
e.l.f. Cosmetics suits shoppers who want broad makeup coverage without moving to a premium price tag, and its Soft Glam Satin Foundation alone carries 36 shades. Entry pricing starts at $4, while the brand scores 10 on trust across our data.
Read the full e.l.f. Cosmetics reviewOlay
Olay suits shoppers who want a single shelf for the whole routine, and it starts at $6.99. The range covers cleansers, moisturisers and serums, and support runs on email, chat and phone. It sells in US only, so shoppers elsewhere should look at Innisfree.
Read the full Olay reviewPros and cons
e.l.f. Cosmetics
Pros
- The Soft Glam Satin Foundation carries 36 shades, ahead of the site median 15.5 shades.
- Cruelty free and vegan products, with Leaping Bunny and PETA.
Cons
- A 14 to 30 day return window gives less slack than a long shopping period for a gift bought early.
- Shade depth sits under the site maximum of 67 shades, so deeper tones may need a second brand.
Olay
Pros
- Cleansers through body-care all sit under the same roof in cleansers, moisturisers and serums
- An entry price of $6.99 keeps a full routine affordable
- Formulas are listed for every skin type in dry, oily and combination
Cons
- Sold in US only, so shoppers elsewhere have no direct store
- Returns of 30 days match the common mark of 30, which is standard rather than generous
Who each suits
e.l.f. Cosmetics
Who it suits
- Shoppers building a full face on a small budget, given entry pricing of $4.
- Readers who filter ranges by cruelty free and vegan labels, both of which this brand meets.
- Shoppers who want daily sun protection in the same basket, since SPF reaches 50.
Who should look elsewhere
- Shoppers after lash and nail colour, since Notino lists foundation, concealer and lipstick against the foundation, concealer and lipstick carried here.
- Shoppers wanting foundation coverage deeper than 36 shades, close to the site maximum 67.
Olay
Who it suits
- Shoppers covering face and body together, given the span of cleansers, moisturisers and serums
- Anyone with sensitive or acne-prone skin, covered in dry, oily and combination
- US buyers, since US covers a single market
Who should look elsewhere
- Shoppers outside the US, since US lists a single market
- Anyone who wants k-beauty formulas, which Innisfree covers in cleansers, moisturisers and serums
- Shoppers who want a shorter list, since cleansers, moisturisers and sunscreen has no serums or retinoids
Questions about each
e.l.f. Cosmetics
What does e.l.f. Cosmetics makeup cost at the entry level?
Makeup prices start at $4 at the brand’s entry level, which sits at the value end of the shelves this site tracks. That figure is the floor for the range rather than a typical basket, so a full face with foundation, mascara and lipstick still adds up beyond it.
How long is the return window?
The return window is 14 to 30 days, and that is the full period for sending a product back. Shoppers testing a shade or a formula at home should make their decision inside it, since anything opened or used can be harder to return once time has passed.
Olay
How much does Olay cost?
Products start at $6.99, which sits at 29 of 172 brands ranked on entry price. The range then climbs through cleansers, moisturisers and serums listed in cleansers, moisturisers and serums, so a full routine is priced piece by piece from that entry point.
Does Olay sell sunscreen?
Yes. Sunscreen is part of cleansers, moisturisers and serums and the factor reaches 40 in the moisturiser range. Daily protection can therefore sit in the same step as moisturising. Innisfree also lists sunscreen in cleansers, moisturisers and serums if you want to weigh the two.
Sources
e.l.f. Cosmetics
- elfcosmetics.com: 12 facts, checked 30 September 2026
Olay
- olay.com: 10 facts, checked 30 September 2026
