Updated 2 October 2026 · BlushCue Editorial Team
Top makeup brands compared in the United States
Offers you can use come first, then value, then score, so a lower score can lead.
- 379.1$11.990 shadesYesPhone, Help centreNot listedNot listed
- Price from
- $11.99
- Not listed
- Foundation shades
- 0 shades
- Vegan range
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Shoppers who want nail colour that is both cruelty free and vegan
- Readers who want hand and foot care for dry skin alongside their manicure
Look elsewhere if
- Anyone building a full face and lip wardrobe, since notino covers foundation, concealer and lipstick
- Readers who need many foundation shades, because OPI lists 0 shades
Read review- Cruelty-free
- Yes
- Legal entity
- Wella Operations US LLC
- Headquarters
- United States
- Founded
- 1980
- Support channels
- Phone, Help centre
- Cost9.2
- Offer8.7
- Trust9.7
- 389.0$7.500 shadesNot listedHelp centreNot listedNot listed
- Price from
- $7.50
- Not listed
- Foundation shades
- 0 shades
- Vegan range
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Shoppers replacing a nail colour who want a long-running brand
- Anyone paying entry level prices for a single product
Look elsewhere if
- Anyone building a full face routine, who should look at foundation, concealer and eyeshadow instead
- Browsers wanting nails and lashes under one roof, where foundation, concealer and lipstick covers both
Read review- Markets
- United States, Australia, Canada, and 5 more
- Founded
- 1981
- Support channels
- Help centre
- Cost9.6
- Offer8.1
- Trust9.6
- 39

Olive & June
Top pickBest for: Nail colour buyers who value a clear returns window over a wide catalogue.
9.0$10.000 shadesNot listedEmail, Help centre +130 daysNot listed- Price from
- $10
- Not listed
- Foundation shades
- 0 shades
- Vegan range
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Nail colour shoppers who want a short decision and a 30 days return window.
- Readers who like support in writing, since support runs on email, help centre and community.
Look elsewhere if
- Anyone shopping complexion, where innisfree lists foundation, concealer and eyeshadow against 0 foundation shades here.
- Shoppers who want a phone or live chat line, since support runs on email, help centre and community only.
Read review- Return window
- 30 days
- Legal entity
- Olive & June, LLC
- Headquarters
- United States
- Founded
- 2013
- Support channels
- Email, Help centre, Community
- Cost9.4
- Offer8.8
- Trust8.6
- 40
Elizabeth Arden
Top pickBest for: Mature skin shoppers who want a wide foundation match and a vegan range.
8.9$28.0024 shadesYesEmail, Phone, Help centre30 daysNot listed- Price from
- $28
- Not listed
- Foundation shades
- 24 shades
- Vegan range
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Anyone matching a deeper or less common tone, given 24 foundation shades.
- Fragrance samplers and subscribers, since samples are offered and a subscription is available.
Look elsewhere if
- Anyone after eyeshadow and brow colour, who gets both from e.l.f. Cosmetics with foundation, concealer and lipstick.
- Nail colour and lash buyers, who find both at notino, listed at foundation, concealer and lipstick.
Read review- Return window
- 30 days
- Markets
- Australia, Canada, China, and 10 more
- Legal entity
- Elizabeth Arden, Inc.
- Headquarters
- United States
- Founded
- 1910
- Support channels
- Email, Phone, Help centre
- Cost8.2
- Offer9.1
- Trust10.0
- 418.9$11.990 shadesYesNot listed14 daysLeaping bunny
- Price from
- $11.99
- Not listed
- Foundation shades
- 0 shades
- Vegan range
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Vegan and cruelty free shoppers who want a named certification behind the claim, listed under leaping bunny.
- US buyers who prefer returns of 14 days and written support through email, help centre and community.
Look elsewhere if
- Foundation and concealer shoppers, who will find more at Innisfree with foundation, concealer and eyeshadow.
- Brows and eyeshadow buyers, better served by e.l.f. Cosmetics at foundation, concealer and lipstick.
Read review- Return window
- 14 days
- Cruelty-free
- Yes
- Certifications
- Leaping bunny
- Cost9.2
- Offer8.7
- Trust8.5
- 42
Hourglass
Top pickBest for: A cruelty free, vegan makeup label with a wide shade range and a long returns window.
8.9$22.0032 shadesYesEmail, Help centre +145 daysNot listed- Price from
- $22
- Not listed
- Foundation shades
- 32 shades
- Vegan range
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Shoppers who want a cruelty free, vegan label with 32 foundation shades and 45 days returns behind the purchase.
- Readers comparing categories as well as price, since foundation, concealer and lipstick covers the core makeup lineup, closer to innisfree at foundation, concealer and eyeshadow than to notino at foundation, concealer and lipstick.
Look elsewhere if
- Shoppers building a basket that needs lashes and nails, since notino lists foundation, concealer and lipstick against the foundation, concealer and lipstick carried here.
Read review- Return window
- 45 days
- Cruelty-free
- Yes
- Markets
- United States, Canada, United Kingdom, and 3 more
- Legal entity
- Kingdom Animalia, LLC
- Headquarters
- United States
- Founded
- 2004
- Support channels
- Email, Help centre, Community
- Cost8.6
- Offer9.3
- Trust9.0
- 438.9Not listed0 shadesNot listedEmail, Help centre +130 daysLeaping bunny
- Price from
- Not listed
- Foundation shades
- 0 shades
- Vegan range
- Not listed
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Shoppers after one well-defined lash range rather than a full makeup bag.
- Readers who want a named certification behind the cruelty free claim, leaping bunny.
Look elsewhere if
- Anyone building a full colour routine: Innisfree lists foundation, concealer and eyeshadow.
- Shoppers wanting lashes, nails and colour in one basket: Notino covers foundation, concealer and lipstick.
Read review- Return window
- 30 days
- Cruelty-free
- Yes
- Certifications
- Leaping bunny
- Markets
- United States, Canada, United Kingdom
- Support channels
- Email, Help centre, Community
- 448.9€16.000 shadesYesEmail, Phone, Help centre14 to 30 daysCosmos
- Price from
- €16
- Not listed
- Foundation shades
- 0 shades
- Vegan range
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Buyers who would rather order from a specialist than from a department store.
Look elsewhere if
- Anyone building a full makeup bag, since innisfree lists foundation, concealer and eyeshadow and covers face, lips and lashes.
- Shoppers who want brows and mascara to sit alongside nails, because e.l.f. Cosmetics lists foundation, concealer and lipstick.
Read review- Return window
- 14 to 30 days
- Certifications
- Cosmos
- Markets
- France, Monaco, Andorra, and 29 more
- Legal entity
- Manucurist
- Headquarters
- France
- Founded
- 1996
- Support channels
- Email, Phone, Help centre
- Cost8.9
- Offer8.8
- Trust9.1
- 45

Rimmel
Top pickBest for: Shoppers who want a wide shade range and a cruelty free, vegan makeup edit in one brand.
8.9Not listed40 shadesYesCommunityNot listedLeaping bunny- Price from
- Not listed
- Foundation shades
- 40 shades
- Vegan range
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Shoppers with harder to match tones, since the lasting finish foundation offers 40 shades.
- Anyone building a full face, lip, eye, brow and nail look from foundation, concealer and lipstick in one brand.
Look elsewhere if
- Anyone who wants nail products without brow products, since innisfree covers foundation, concealer and eyeshadow and leaves brows out.
Read review- Cruelty-free
- Yes
- Certifications
- Leaping bunny
- Markets
- United Kingdom, Spain, France, and 7 more
- Support channels
- Community
- 46
ILIA
Top pickBest for: Makeup shoppers who want many foundation tones, cruelty free and vegan formulas, and a long return window.
8.8€20.4030 shadesYesNot listed60 daysLeaping bunny- Price from
- €20.40
- Not listed
- Foundation shades
- 30 shades
- Vegan range
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Anyone building a full face on one brand, since foundation, concealer and lipstick covers colour and brow products together, where innisfree's foundation, concealer and eyeshadow stops short of brows.
Look elsewhere if
- Shoppers who want to try before they buy, because samples are not offered and a return is the only fallback.
- Anyone after lashes or nail products, which notino-pt lists in foundation, concealer and lipstick and ILIA's foundation, concealer and lipstick does not.
Read review- Return window
- 60 days
- Cruelty-free
- Yes
- Certifications
- Leaping bunny
- Cost8.5
- Offer9.1
- Trust8.8
- 47

Kosas
Top pickBest for: A cruelty free everyday colour edit with a deep foundation range and returns handled online.
8.8€18.0036 shadesNoNot listed30 daysLeaping bunny- Price from
- €18
- Not listed
- Foundation shades
- 36 shades
- Vegan range
- No
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- Shoppers who want foundation, concealer, lips, eyes and brows from a single cruelty free label, without a second brand in the basket.
- Anyone who needs a wide shade choice and wants to match a tone closely, with 36 foundation shades to work from.
Look elsewhere if
- Shoppers after lashes and nails, who should start with notino: its foundation, concealer and lipstick covers both while Kosas covers foundation, concealer and lipstick.
- Anyone who needs a vegan formula, since Kosas is not vegan, and cruelty free status does not change what sits in the bottle.
Read review- Return window
- 30 days
- Cruelty-free
- Yes
- Certifications
- Leaping bunny
- Cost8.7
- Offer8.9
- Trust8.9
- 48

Milk Makeup
Top pickBest for: US shoppers building a cruelty free, vegan everyday makeup basket with a choice of 15 foundation shades.
8.8$20.1615 shadesYesEmail, Help centre30 daysNot listed- Price from
- $20.16
- Not listed
- Foundation shades
- 15 shades
- Vegan range
- Yes
Is it right for you?
Fits you if
- US shoppers who want cruelty free and vegan colour across face, lip and eye from one focused brand rather than a general retailer such as notino.
- Foundation buyers who want a real shade choice, with 15 shades to work through and 30 days to send a mismatch back.
Look elsewhere if
- Shoppers outside the US, who should start with Innisfree or notino instead: Milk Makeup lists US as its only shipping market.
- Anyone after nail colour, since nails are absent from foundation, concealer and lipstick while Innisfree and notino both list them.
Read review- Return window
- 30 days
- Cruelty-free
- Yes
- Markets
- United States
- Legal entity
- Milk Makeup LLC
- Headquarters
- United States
- Support channels
- Email, Help centre