Updated 2 October 2026 · BlushCue Editorial Team

Top makeup brands compared

126 brands, ranked on the terms we checked.

Offers you can use come first, then value, then score, so a lower score can lead.

What matters most
  • 73

    Mylee

    Top pick

    Best for: Cheap lashes, brows and nails from a cruelty free, vegan brand

    9.3
    £3.50
    0 shades
    30 days
    Yes
    Not listed
    Price from
    £3.50
    Not listed
    Foundation shades
    0 shades
    Return window
    30 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Vegan and cruelty free buyers who value a peta listing alongside a 30 day return window.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Anyone building a full face kit: innisfree and e.l.f. Cosmetics both sell foundation, while Mylee lists 0 foundation shades.
    • Shoppers who want one store for everything: notino covers foundation, concealer and lipstick against the narrower nails, brows and lashes here.
    Cruelty-free
    Yes
    Vegan range
    Yes
    Certifications
    Peta
    • Cost9.8
    • Offer9.1
    • Trust8.7
    Read review
  • 74

    Revolution Beauty

    Top pick

    Best for: Low-cost face and hair basics, ordered in one basket, with a long returns window and a deep foundation shade range.

    9.3
    £1.00
    44 shades
    28 days
    No
    Not listed
    Price from
    £1
    Not listed
    Foundation shades
    44 shades
    Return window
    28 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers building a low-cost everyday look who want foundation, concealer, lipstick, mascara, eyeshadow and brows from one place.
    • Anyone matching a hard-to-find tone, since the shade count sits well clear of what most brands on the site manage.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Nail and lash buyers, since notino covers foundation, concealer and lipstick where this brand's foundation, concealer and lipstick stops short.
    Cruelty-free
    Yes
    Vegan range
    No
    Certifications
    Peta
    • Cost10.0
    • Offer8.9
    • Trust8.7
    Read review
  • 75

    Anastasia Beverly Hills

    Top pick

    Best for: Colour-match shoppers who want brows, lashes and foundation from a single label with returns open for 30 days.

    9.2
    €10.95
    44 shades
    30 days
    Not listed
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    Price from
    €10.95
    Not listed
    Foundation shades
    44 shades
    Return window
    30 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers who want brows, lashes and face colour together: e.l.f. Cosmetics lists foundation, concealer and lipstick without lashes, so this label covers more of a full routine.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Nail buyers: innisfree lists nails in foundation, concealer and eyeshadow and notino lists them in foundation, concealer and lipstick, while brows, eyeshadow and mascara does not.
    Markets
    United States, United Kingdom, Canada, and 1 more
    Legal entity
    Anastasia Beverly Hills, LLC
    Headquarters
    United States
    Support channels
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    Read review
  • 76

    Maybelline

    Top pick

    Best for: Shoppers who want many foundation shades from a mass market brand that is cruelty free.

    9.2
    $11.99
    40 shades
    Not listed
    Not listed
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    Price from
    $11.99
    Not listed
    Foundation shades
    40 shades
    Return window
    Not listed
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Buyers who only consider cruelty free brands and want a full range from a single label.
    • People who would rather ring a phone line than type, given email, phone and help centre.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Anyone after nail or lash products: notino lists foundation, concealer and lipstick.
    • Shoppers who want nails inside a Korean range, which innisfree covers in foundation, concealer and eyeshadow.
    Cruelty-free
    Yes
    Legal entity
    L'Oreal USA, Inc.
    Headquarters
    United States
    Support channels
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    Read review
  • 77

    Mineralogie Makeup

    Top pick

    Best for: A cruelty free, vegan US mineral range with a deep shade spread and phone support.

    9.2
    $11.00
    30 shades
    30 days
    Yes
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    Price from
    $11
    Not listed
    Foundation shades
    30 shades
    Return window
    30 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Anyone who wants a deep shade spread in a cruelty free, vegan mineral range, since the loose powder carries 30 shades.
    • US shoppers who would rather settle a shade question out loud, since help runs on email, phone and help centre.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Shoppers who want lashes and nails in the same basket, since notino covers foundation, concealer and lipstick.
    • Anyone ordering from outside US, where a multi-country range is the better bet.
    Cruelty-free
    Yes
    Vegan range
    Yes
    Markets
    United States
    Headquarters
    United States
    Support channels
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    Read review
  • 78

    Bobbi Brown

    Top pick

    Best for: Shoppers who match a foundation shade and want face, colour and brow products from one brand.

    9.1
    $35.00
    53 shades
    Not listed
    Not listed
    Not listed
    Price from
    $35
    Not listed
    Foundation shades
    53 shades
    Return window
    Not listed
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers who have found a shade match in a wide range and want to reorder the same face products
    • Anyone building one routine across foundation, concealer, colour and brows

    Look elsewhere if

    • Budget shoppers after the lowest entry price, who would be better served by e.l.f. Cosmetics
    • Shoppers who want lashes and nails in the same brand, who would find both at Notino
    Founded
    1991
    • Cost8.1
    • Offer9.9
    • Trust9.2
    Read review
  • 79

    OPI

    Top pick

    Best for: Nail colour and hand and foot care at a mid-range price, from $11.99.

    9.1
    $11.99
    0 shades
    Not listed
    Yes
    Phone, Help centre
    Price from
    $11.99
    Not listed
    Foundation shades
    0 shades
    Return window
    Not listed
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers who want nail colour that is both cruelty free and vegan
    • Readers who want hand and foot care for dry skin alongside their manicure

    Look elsewhere if

    • Anyone building a full face and lip wardrobe, since notino covers foundation, concealer and lipstick
    • Readers who need many foundation shades, because OPI lists 0 shades
    Cruelty-free
    Yes
    Vegan range
    Yes
    Legal entity
    Wella Operations US LLC
    Headquarters
    United States
    Founded
    1980
    Support channels
    Phone, Help centre
    • Cost9.2
    • Offer8.7
    • Trust9.7
    Read review
  • 80

    Essie

    Top pick

    Best for: A low entry price on an established nail brand.

    9.0
    $7.50
    0 shades
    Not listed
    Not listed
    Help centre
    Price from
    $7.50
    Not listed
    Foundation shades
    0 shades
    Return window
    Not listed
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers replacing a nail colour who want a long-running brand
    • Anyone paying entry level prices for a single product

    Look elsewhere if

    • Anyone building a full face routine, who should look at foundation, concealer and eyeshadow instead
    • Browsers wanting nails and lashes under one roof, where foundation, concealer and lipstick covers both
    Markets
    United States, Australia, Canada, and 5 more
    Founded
    1981
    Support channels
    Help centre
    • Cost9.6
    • Offer8.1
    • Trust9.6
    Read review
  • 81

    Olive & June

    Top pick

    Best for: Nail colour buyers who value a clear returns window over a wide catalogue.

    9.0
    $10.00
    0 shades
    30 days
    Not listed
    Email, Help centre +1
    Price from
    $10
    Not listed
    Foundation shades
    0 shades
    Return window
    30 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Nail colour shoppers who want a short decision and a 30 days return window.
    • Readers who like support in writing, since support runs on email, help centre and community.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Anyone shopping complexion, where innisfree lists foundation, concealer and eyeshadow against 0 foundation shades here.
    • Shoppers who want a phone or live chat line, since support runs on email, help centre and community only.
    Legal entity
    Olive & June, LLC
    Headquarters
    United States
    Founded
    2013
    Support channels
    Email, Help centre, Community
    • Cost9.4
    • Offer8.8
    • Trust8.6
    Read review
  • 82

    Elizabeth Arden

    Top pick

    Best for: Mature skin shoppers who want a wide foundation match and a vegan range.

    8.9
    $28.00
    24 shades
    30 days
    Yes
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    Price from
    $28
    Not listed
    Foundation shades
    24 shades
    Return window
    30 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Anyone matching a deeper or less common tone, given 24 foundation shades.
    • Fragrance samplers and subscribers, since samples are offered and a subscription is available.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Anyone after eyeshadow and brow colour, who gets both from e.l.f. Cosmetics with foundation, concealer and lipstick.
    • Nail colour and lash buyers, who find both at notino, listed at foundation, concealer and lipstick.
    Vegan range
    Yes
    Markets
    Australia, Canada, China, and 10 more
    Legal entity
    Elizabeth Arden, Inc.
    Headquarters
    United States
    Founded
    1910
    Support channels
    Email, Phone, Help centre
    • Cost8.2
    • Offer9.1
    • Trust10.0
    Read review
  • 83

    Glamnetic

    Top pick

    Best for: Cruelty free, vegan lashes and nails at an entry price of $11.99.

    8.9
    $11.99
    0 shades
    14 days
    Yes
    Not listed
    Price from
    $11.99
    Not listed
    Foundation shades
    0 shades
    Return window
    14 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Vegan and cruelty free shoppers who want a named certification behind the claim, listed under leaping bunny.
    • US buyers who prefer returns of 14 days and written support through email, help centre and community.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Foundation and concealer shoppers, who will find more at Innisfree with foundation, concealer and eyeshadow.
    • Brows and eyeshadow buyers, better served by e.l.f. Cosmetics at foundation, concealer and lipstick.
    Cruelty-free
    Yes
    Vegan range
    Yes
    Certifications
    Leaping bunny
    • Cost9.2
    • Offer8.7
    • Trust8.5
    Read review
  • 84

    Hourglass

    Top pick

    Best for: A cruelty free, vegan makeup label with a wide shade range and a long returns window.

    8.9
    $22.00
    32 shades
    45 days
    Yes
    Email, Help centre +1
    Price from
    $22
    Not listed
    Foundation shades
    32 shades
    Return window
    45 days
    Is it right for you?

    Fits you if

    • Shoppers who want a cruelty free, vegan label with 32 foundation shades and 45 days returns behind the purchase.
    • Readers comparing categories as well as price, since foundation, concealer and lipstick covers the core makeup lineup, closer to innisfree at foundation, concealer and eyeshadow than to notino at foundation, concealer and lipstick.

    Look elsewhere if

    • Shoppers building a basket that needs lashes and nails, since notino lists foundation, concealer and lipstick against the foundation, concealer and lipstick carried here.
    Cruelty-free
    Yes
    Vegan range
    Yes
    Markets
    United States, Canada, United Kingdom, and 3 more
    Legal entity
    Kingdom Animalia, LLC
    Headquarters
    United States
    Founded
    2004
    Support channels
    Email, Help centre, Community
    • Cost8.6
    • Offer9.3
    • Trust9.0
    Read review
The price to start, as the brand lists it, set against the others in its category. Read moreWhat a new customer gets to begin with, and on what terms. Read moreCompany, licence and policy details we could check. Read more

About this ranking

Makeup buying turns on a few plain numbers: what a product costs the first time you buy it, what the range covers, and where the brand will actually ship to you. The central trade-off is entry price against shelf depth. The cheapest sellers here tend to be fragrance and k-beauty operations with little or no colour, while the widest foundation shade counts sit at the upper end of the price list. Support matters for the same reason: a wrong tone is settled faster by chat and phone than by email alone. Prices appear as each brand publishes them, in the currency of its own store, so they compare cleanly within a currency rather than across the list.

How we picked

Each brand is scored on three weighted factors. Cost reads the published starting price against the spread across the category. Offer reads returns, product types, markets and support channels, the parts that decide whether a first order becomes a second. Trust reads cruelty free and vegan status, certifications and the legal entity behind the brand. Figures are drawn from each brand's own pricing, shipping, returns, policy, help and store pages, with range figures taken from the site's data set. A brand is neither penalised nor credited for a figure it does not publish, so a gap in the record is not read as a weakness. Where a figure is published as a range, it is reproduced as the brand states it, without trimming.

How we rank

Picks by need

  • Best forCheap lashes, brows and nails from a cruelty free, vegan brand

    Mylee

    Products start at £3.50, the brand states it is cruelty free and vegan, and PETA appears among its certifications. Returns run 30 days and support runs on email, chat and help centre, with live chat included.

What to look for

What the opening price looks like
Judge each brand on where its starting figure sits, since that is what a first order actually costs.
How many foundation shades
Shade count decides whether a brand can match your skin. The category median is 24 shades, the upper quartile reaches 36.5 and the widest range in the data is 67.
What happens if you change your mind
Returns matter as much as the opening price on a first order. Across the wider data the median return window is 30 days, with a lower quartile of 30 and an upper quartile of 60, so a longer published window is a real offer rather than a footnote.
Whether formulas suit your values
Check cruelty free and vegan status before colour. Certifications are listed per brand where the brand publishes them.
How you get an answer afterwards
A wrong shade match is settled faster by chat or a phone line than by email alone.
What the shelf holds
Category share matters when the cheapest brand is not a colour brand. In this ranking 6% of the mix is k-beauty, 21% sunscreen and 23% body care, so read the product list before the price tag.

Questions

Which brand here is the cheapest to start with?

Each brand publishes its own starting price in the currency of its store, so compare within a currency.

Which brand offers the most foundation shades?

MAC Cosmetics leads with 67 foundation shades, ahead of Clinique at 50 shades and YesStyle at 40 shades, while e.l.f. Cosmetics and The Ordinary both list 36 shades. The category median sits at 24 shades, and fragrance seller Notino lists 0 shades. Shade range is why MAC carries the highest foundation shade count label here.

How do I get help after buying?

Email and a help centre are close to standard on this list, and most brands add chat or a phone line. Innisfree offers email, chat and phone, e.l.f. Cosmetics offers email, phone and help centre and YesStyle offers email, chat and help centre, so chat and phone are the gaps for shoppers who would rather not wait on email. Across the category, 97% of brands run a help centre and 52% take phone calls.

How long do I have to change my mind?

Windows differ widely here. The Ordinary gives 365 days, Notino gives 90 days and Deluvia gives 60 days, while e.l.f. Cosmetics offers 14 to 30 days and L'Atelier du Sourcil offers 15 days. Ulta Beauty, MAC Cosmetics and Clinique each publish 30 days, which suits buyers who want a middle ground.

Are the cheaper brands cruelty free or vegan?

Price and ethics do not move together here. e.l.f. The Ordinary is cruelty free and vegan with leaping bunny and peta. Ulta Beauty, Deluvia and L'Atelier du Sourcil state cruelty free, and L'Atelier du Sourcil is vegan too.

Which brand ships to the most markets?

Notino covers the most ground with CZ, SK and PL, followed by MAC Cosmetics at US, CA and MX, e.l.f. Cosmetics at US, CA and IN and L'Atelier du Sourcil at FR, AD and BE. At the narrow end, Ulta Beauty sells into US and Deluvia into US, so shoppers living elsewhere should check a seller's own market list before ordering.

Keep comparing