Updated 17 October 2026 · BlushCue Editorial Team

Abracadabra NYC review

Abracadabra NYC logo

Abracadabra NYCNo. 3 of 46 in lashes and nails

9.1
Visit Abracadabra NYC
9.1
out of 10No. 3 of 46 in lashes and nailsFacts checked 30 Sep 2026

Best for: Low cost US makeup baskets that include both lashes and nails.

Price from
$8.95
Foundation shades
0 shades
Markets
United States
Headquarters
United States

Alternatives to Abracadabra NYC

See all 46 ranked →

Our verdict

Abracadabra NYC suits US shoppers who want a broad makeup range at a modest entry price, though its foundation range is thin. It scores 9.1 overall, with prices from $8.95 and returns limited to 0 days, so shade depth matters here.

Fits you if

  • Shoppers in the US building a low cost everyday basket from $8.95.
  • People who want lashes and nails in the same range as foundation and lipstick, given foundation, concealer and lipstick.
  • Anyone happy to buy once rather than send back, since the return window is 0 days.

Look elsewhere if

  • Notino.cz, if brows matter to you: its listed types run foundation, concealer and lipstick, adding a category Abracadabra NYC does not carry.
  • innisfree, if a deeper foundation line matters to you, against 0 shades here.
  • notino, if you would rather price the same categories across two retailers before settling on the $8.95 entry point.

Key facts

Cost and Offer
Price from
$8.95
Foundation shades
0 shades
Lab-grown diamonds
No
Other facts
Markets
United States
Products
Foundation, Concealer, Lipstick, Mascara, Eyeshadow, Lashes, Nails
Company
Headquarters
United States
Founded
1981
Support channels
Email, Phone, Help centre
Official website
Visit Abracadabra NYC

Facts checked 30 September 2026, 7 sources

Pros and cons

Pros

  • The range spans foundation, concealer and lipstick, putting lashes and nails next to everyday face colour.
  • Compared with innisfree, whose listed types are foundation, concealer and eyeshadow, Abracadabra NYC adds lashes.
  • Support runs on email, phone and help centre, so email, a phone line and a help centre are all available.
  • Founded in 1981 and based in the US, this is a long trading history rather than a new label.

Cons

  • The return window is 0 days, so a product cannot be sent back once it arrives.
  • The listed markets are US, so shoppers elsewhere are ordering across borders.
  • Lab grown stones are not offered in the jewellery, which rules the brand out for that kind of buyer.

Core features

Two things decide the trade-off here, and both are about commitment rather than choice. Foundation shades come to 0 shades, so depth is the first thing to check before you order. The return window is 0 days, which means a shade or a finish that does not suit has no second chance once the parcel is open. Together they make this a brand for shoppers who already know what they want.

How it compares on our data

On the site’s ranking, Abracadabra NYC sits at 44 of 76 brands on foundation shades, and at 28 of 74 brands on price from. Read those two positions side by side and the pattern is clear: the price position is stronger than the shade position. Combine it with a return window of 0 days and the message for buyers is that you pay little and you commit fully.

The company behind it

Abracadabra NYC is based in the US and has been trading since 1981. Support runs on email, phone and help centre, so there is a help centre and a phone line alongside email. For a brand with a history stretching back to 1981, that spread of channels is a real convenience, particularly for questions about shades and finishes that are easier to talk through than to type.

Questions

How much does Abracadabra NYC cost at the entry end?

Prices start at $8.95. On the site’s ranking of brands by entry price, Abracadabra NYC sits at 28 of 74, which puts it towards the cheaper end of the makeup brands measured. Those prices cover colour, lashes and nails from a US store.

Can I return makeup from Abracadabra NYC?

The return window is 0 days, so there is no time to send a product back once it arrives. That makes the shade and the finish the deciding factors rather than a home trial. Read the shade listing and the finish notes carefully before ordering, because nothing goes back afterwards.

How many foundation shades does Abracadabra NYC offer?

Foundation shades come to 0 shades. Foundation still sits among the listed product types, so the category exists without a deep shade run to pick from. On that measure the brand ranks 44 of 76 brands.

What does the Abracadabra NYC range cover?

The listed product types are foundation, concealer and lipstick. Lashes and nails sit in the same range as foundation, concealer, lipstick, mascara and eyeshadow, which suits shoppers who would rather build one basket than mix retailers. Brows are not part of the listed range.

Where does Abracadabra NYC ship?

The listed markets are US, and the brand is based in the US. Shoppers in other countries are ordering across borders rather than through a local checkout, which adds transit time and import steps to every basket.

How can I contact Abracadabra NYC?

Support runs on email, phone and help centre. Email, a phone line and a help centre are all listed, so there is more than one route to an answer. Questions about shades, finishes or an order already placed can go through the phone line or the help centre instead of written contact alone.

When was Abracadabra NYC founded?

Abracadabra NYC was founded in 1981 and is based in the US. The same page set lists US as the market it delivers to, so the store has a long trading history behind a single home market.

Does the Abracadabra NYC jewellery use lab grown stones?

Lab grown stones are not part of the jewellery on offer, and the makeup range listed for the brand sits alongside it. Shoppers after lab grown stones, or after a wide foundation shade run to match their skin, are better served by a different retailer.

Sources

Compiled from 7 source pages, checked 30 September 2026. We did not open an account.